Document from CIS Legislation database © 2003-2021 SojuzPravoInform LLC

The document ceased to be valid since February 14, 2016 according to Item 2 of the joint Order of the deputy. The Minister of Education and Science of the Republic of Kazakhstan and the Acting Minister of national economy of the Republic of Kazakhstan of December 31, 2015 No. 719, on December 31, 2015 No. 843

JOINT ORDER OF I.O. MINISTER OF EDUCATION AND SCIENCE OF THE REPUBLIC OF KAZAKHSTAN AND I.O. MINISTER OF NATIONAL ECONOMY OF THE REPUBLIC OF KAZAKHSTAN

of July 24, 2015 No. 479, on July 31, 2015 No. 583

About approval of criteria for evaluation of risk degree and forms of checking sheets on checks behind education system

According to the subitem 2) of Item 1 of Article 11, with Item 3 of Article 13, and Item 1 of article 15 of the Law of the Republic of Kazakhstan of January 6, 2011 "About the state control and supervision in the Republic of Kazakhstan" we ORDER:

1. Approve:

1) criteria for evaluation of risk degree on checks behind education system, according to appendix 1 to this joint order;

2) forms of checking sheets in the field of the state control of education system, according to appendices 2-3 to this joint order;

2. Declare invalid the joint order of the Minister of Education and Science of the Republic of Kazakhstan of July 23, 2013 No. 293 and the First Deputy Premier-Ministra of the Republic of Kazakhstan - the Minister of Regional Development of the Republic of Kazakhstan of July 26, 2013 No. 160/7118 "About approval of criteria for evaluation of risk degree and forms of checking sheets in the field of private entrepreneurship on checks behind education system" (registered in the Register of state registration of regulatory legal acts of the Republic of Kazakhstan for No. 8641, No. 309 published in the Kazakhstanskaya Pravda newspaper of November 6, 2013 (27583)).

3. (Nyusupov S.) in the procedure established by the legislation to provide to committee on control in the field of science and education of the Ministry of Education and Science of the Republic of Kazakhstan:

1) state registration of this joint order in the Ministry of Justice of the Republic of Kazakhstan;

2) after passing of state registration in the Ministry of Justice of the Republic of Kazakhstan official publication of this joint order;

3) placement of this joint order on Internet resource of the Ministry of Education and Science of the Republic of Kazakhstan.

4. To impose control of execution of this joint order on the vice-Minister of Education and Science of the Republic of Kazakhstan T. Balykbayev.

5. This joint order becomes effective after ten calendar days after day of its first official publication.

Acting minister of science and education of the Republic of Kazakhstan

T. Balykbayev

 Acting minister of national economy of the Republic of Kazakhstan

T. Zhasylykov

It is approved

Chairman of Committee on legal statistics and special accounting of the Prosecutor General's Office of the Republic of Kazakhstan

July 30, 2015

 

 

Aytpayeva S.

Appendix 1

to the joint Order of the acting minister of science and education of the Republic of Kazakhstan and the acting minister of national economy of the Republic of Kazakhstan of July 24, 2015 No. 479, on July 31, 2015 No. 583

Criteria for evaluation of risk degree on checks behind education system

1. Criteria for evaluation of risk degree on checks behind education system (further - Criteria) are developed for selection of the checked subjects (objects) for the purpose of conducting checks behind education system, and also forms of the checking sheets approved according to Item 3 of Article 13 and Item 1 of article 15 of the Law of the Republic of Kazakhstan "About the state control and supervision in the Republic of Kazakhstan".

2. In these Criteria the following concepts are used:

1) risk - probability of damnification as a result of activities of the checked subject (object) to legitimate interests of physical persons and legal entities, the states, probability of decline in quality of the provided educational services of education by the organizations;

2) system of risks assessment - the complex of actions held by control facility and supervision for the purpose of appointment and conducting checks;

3) criteria for evaluation of risk degree - set of the quantitative and qualitative indexes connected with direct activities of the checked subject, the features of industry development and factors influencing this development, the checked subjects allowing to carry to different risk degrees;

4) objective criteria for evaluation of risk degree (further - objective criteria) - the criteria for evaluation of risk degree used for selection of the checked subjects (objects) depending on risk degree in certain field of activity and which are not depending directly on the separate checked subject (object);

5) subjective criteria for evaluation of risk degree (further - subjective criteria) - the criteria for evaluation of risk degree used for selection of the checked subjects (objects) depending on results of activities of the specific checked subject (object);

6) the checked subjects - physical persons, legal entities, including state bodies behind which activities control is exercised.

7) the checked objects - the property which is on the property right or other legal cause at the checked subject, subject to control.

3. Criteria are created by means of objective and subjective criteria.

4. The checked subjects (objects) are distributed on risk degrees (high and not carried to high degree) taking into account one of the following objective criteria:

1) the checked subjects (objects) which educational activities are conducted according to state standards of education or concerning which the allowing or notifying procedure is entered concern to group of high risk. The following checked subjects concern to them:

the organizations of education realizing general education training programs of preschool education and training;

the organizations of education realizing general education training programs of primary education;

the organizations of education realizing general education training programs of the main secondary education;

the organizations of education realizing general education training programs of general secondary education;

the organizations of education realizing educational training programs of technical and professional education;

the organizations of education realizing professional training programs of postsecondary education;

the organizations of education realizing professional training programs of the higher and postgraduate education.

Selective, unscheduled inspections and other forms of control are applied to the checked subjects (objects) carried to high risk.

2) the checked subjects (objects) conducting additional educational activities or exercising control of education concern to the group which is not carried to high risk.

Unscheduled inspections and other forms of control are applied to the checked subjects (objects) which are not carried to high risk.

5. Subjective criteria are applied to the checked subjects (objects) carried by objective criteria to high risk.

6. The following information sources are applied to determination of subjective criteria:

1) results of monitoring of the reporting and the data represented by the checked subject including by means of the automated information systems;

2) results of the previous checks, at the same time, severity of violations (rough, considerable, insignificant) is established in case of non-compliance with the requirements of the legislation reflected in checking sheets;

3) availability and the number of the confirmed claims and addresses;

4) results of external assessment of educational achievements, results of assessment of level of professional readiness and assignment of qualification on professions (specialties) of the technical and servicing work;

5) results of other forms of control;

6) data of state bodies, mass media.

7. Subjective criteria are determined according to appendices to these Criteria.

8. Assessment of the subjective criteria of organization activity of education realizing general education training programs of preschool education and training is performed according to appendix 1 to these Criteria.

9. Assessment of the subjective criteria of organization activity of education realizing general education training programs of primary, main secondary and general secondary education is performed according to appendices 2, of 3, 4 to these Criteria.

10. Assessment of the subjective criteria of organization activity of education realizing educational training programs of technical and professional education is performed according to appendix 5 to these Criteria.

11. Assessment of the subjective criteria of organization activity of education realizing professional training programs of postsecondary education is performed according to appendix 6 to these Criteria.

12. Assessment of the subjective criteria of organization activity of education realizing professional training programs of the higher and postgraduate education is performed according to appendix 7 to these Criteria.

13. Subjective criteria of violation are divided into three severity: rough, considerable, insignificant.

14. In the presence of one violation of rough degree concerning the checked subject (object) selective check is carried out.

15. In case of lack of outstanding requirements of rough degree, the total indicator of violations of considerable and insignificant degree is determined.

In case of measure definition of violations of considerable degree the coefficient of 0,7 is applied and this indicator is calculated by the following formula:

Формула 1 к СП от 24.07.2015 №479

16. On risk exponents the checked subject (object) belongs:

1) to high risk - in case of exponent of risk from 60 to 100 and concerning it selective check is carried out;

2) not carried to high risk - in case of exponent of risk from 0 to 60 and concerning it selective check is not carried out.

17. Frequency rate of carrying out selective check is determined by results of the carried-out analysis and assessment of the received data on subjective criteria and cannot be more often than once a year.

18. Selective checks are carried out based on lists of the selective checks created for year by results of the carried-out analysis and assessment which go to authorized body on legal statistics and special accounting not later than fifteen calendar days prior to the beginning of the corresponding accounting period in time.

19. Lists of selective checks are constituted taking into account:

1) priority of the checked subjects (objects) with the greatest exponent of risk by subjective criteria;

2) loads of the officials performing checks, state body.

Appendix 1

to Criteria for evaluation of risk degree on checks behind education system

Subjective criteria of organization activity of education, realizing general education training programs of preschool education and training

Criteria

Extent of violation

1. Results of monitoring of the reporting and the data represented by the checked subject including by means of the automated information systems

1.1 Not submission of the reporting in the field of education

considerable

1.2 Discrepancy of data regarding general information on the organization of education and the contingent of pupils in different types of the reporting

insignificant

1.3 Discrepancy of data regarding data on educational process, material resources and pedagogical personnel in different types of the reporting

considerable

1.4 Not observance of requirements of the state obligatory standard of education and standard curricula on amount of the provided academic load

rough

1.5 Lack of educational and methodical literature

insignificant

1.6 Lack of sports, musical halls and certain game rooms in kindergartens

insignificant

1.7 Availability of the teachers who do not have vocational pedagogical or professional education on the corresponding profile or post

rough

1.8 Absence of the pedagogical workers having qualification categories on the corresponding profile

insignificant

1.9 Violation by pedagogical workers of terms of advanced training

insignificant

1.10 Exceeding of regulations of fullness of children in groups

insignificant

1.11 Lack of registration in the state electronic register of permissions and notifications

rough

2. Results of the previous checks (severity is established in case of non-compliance with following requirements)

2.1 Accomplishment of obligations and regulations of pedagogical ethics by the pedagogical worker (it is checked in the presence of addresses)

considerable

2.2 Respect for the principle of state policy regarding prohibition of creation and activities of organizational structures of political parties and the religious organizations (associations) in the organizations of education

rough

2.3 Advanced training of the managerial personnel, pedagogical and scientists of the organizations of education at least once in five years

insignificant

2.4 Implementation of educational activities according to standard curricula

rough

2.5 Observance of the maximum admissible amount of week academic load of pupils and students of all age levels

rough

2.6 Coupon availability about acceptance of the notification on the beginning of activities by means of the state information system of permissions and notifications

rough

2.7 Availability constituent and documents of title of the organization of education

considerable

2.8 Realization in full general education programs of preschool education and training

rough

2.9 Passing by pedagogical workers of certification at least once in five years

insignificant

2.10 Passing by the head of the organization of formation of certification once in three years

insignificant

2.11 Functioning of collegiate organs of management of the organization of education

considerable

2.12 Security with the personnel having the pedagogical education confirmed by documents of the state sample on appropriate level of education and qualification

rough

2.13 Non-admission to work in the organization of formation of persons to which pedagogical activities are prohibited by the court verdict or the medical certificate, and also having criminal record which is not extinguished or is not removed in the procedure established by the law

rough

2.14 Accomplishment of obligations by the head or other official of the organization of education for safety of health of pupils, students and the staff of the organizations of education during teaching and educational process

considerable

2.15 Ensuring the functions determined by the Charter of the preschool organization

considerable

2.16 Compliance of the number of staff of the organization of education to Standard states of employees of the state organizations of education and to the list of positions of pedagogical workers and persons equated to them

considerable

2.17 Providing children with the current medical observation by the health workers entering into staff of the preschool organization

considerable

2.18 Providing the balanced food of children

considerable

2.19 Availability of the agreements regulating relations between the preschool organization and parents or legal representatives of parents

insignificant

2.20 Availability of regulations, job descriptions of the workers developed by the preschool organization

insignificant

2.21 Creation of conditions for implementation of educational and educational process in the preschool organization according to requirements of the state obligatory standard of formation of preschool education and training

rough

2.22 Preserving the place for the child in the preschool organization for disease, treatment and improvement in medical, sanatorium or other organizations or for labor leave of parents or legal representatives

insignificant

2.23 Expel of children from the preschool organization in case of untimely monthly payment for content of the child (it is checked in the presence of addresses)

insignificant

2.24 Expel of children from the preschool organization in case of the omission the child more than one month without valid excuse and without the warning to administration (it is checked in the presence of addresses)

insignificant

2.25 Expel of children from the preschool organization in the presence of the medical contraindications interfering its stay based on the reference of the medical advisory commission (it is checked in the presence of addresses)

insignificant

3. Availability and the number of the confirmed claims and addresses

3.1 Availability of 1-2 confirmed claims and addresses from physical persons and legal entities which rights are violated

considerable

3.2 Availability 3 (three) and more confirmed claims and addresses from physical persons and legal entities which rights are violated

rough

4. Results of the state certification

4.1 It is not certified for results of the state certification

considerable

4.2 Not execution of the instruction (resolution) on elimination of the violations revealed during the state certification of the organizations of education for discrepancy of educational services to requirements of the state obligatory standard of education

rough

5. Data of state bodies, mass media

5.1 Availability of data in mass media on violations in work of the organization of education

insignificant

5.2 Availability of instructions of bodies of prosecutor's office about the violations revealed in education organization activity

considerable

Appendix 2

to Criteria for evaluation of risk degree on checks behind education system

Subjective criteria of organization activity of education, realizing general education training programs of primary education

Criteria

Extent of violation

1. Results of monitoring of the reporting and the data represented by the checked subject including by means of the automated information systems

1.1 Not submission of the reporting in the field of education

considerable

1.2 Discrepancy of data regarding general information on the organization of education and school enrollment in different types of the reporting

insignificant

1.3 Discrepancy of data regarding data on educational process, material resources and pedagogical personnel in different types of the reporting

considerable

1.4 Availability of the teachers who do not have vocational pedagogical or professional education on the corresponding profile or post

rough

1.5 Discrepancy of high-quality list of teachers to the qualification requirements imposed when licensing educational activities

considerable

1.6 Availability of subjects of the standard curriculum which are not taught because of the absence of specialists

rough

1.7 Absence of library

considerable

1.8 Availability of the pupils who are not provided with textbooks

rough

1.9 Lack of the gym

considerable

1.10 Lack of the standard sports equipment in the gym

considerable

1.11 Availability of repeaters

considerable

1.12 Availability of the first or the graduation classes combined with other classes

considerable

1.13 Availability of three-shift training at school

considerable

1.14 Lack of the license for educational activities

rough

2. Results of the previous checks (severity is established in case of non-compliance with following requirements)

2.1 Availability constituent and documents of title of the organization of education

considerable

2.2 Respect for the principle of state policy regarding prohibition of creation and activities of organizational structures of political parties and the religious organizations (associations) in the organizations of education

rough

2.3 Accomplishment of obligations and regulations of pedagogical ethics by the pedagogical worker (it is checked in the presence of addresses)

considerable

2.4 Passing by the head of the organization of formation of certification once in three years

insignificant

2.5 Advanced training of the managerial personnel, pedagogical and scientists of the organizations of education at least once in five years

insignificant

2.6 Accomplishment of invariant component of the standard curriculum

rough

2.7 Compliance of the maximum amount of week academic load of students, including all types of cool and out-of-class study (optional, individual and kruzhkovy occupations), to the state obligatory standard of secondary education (initial)

rough

2.8 Division of class into 2 groups in the city general education organizations at filling class in 24 and more students, in rural - in 20 and more students, in small schools - at least 10 students when carrying out lessons:

1) on Kazakh in 1-4 classes with not Kazakh of training;

2) on Russian in 3-4 classes with the Kazakh and Uigur, Tajik and Uzbek languages of training;

3) on foreign language in 1-4 classes.

In the presence in class of children with limited opportunities in development division of class is performed at the rate of reduction of total quantity of pupils by three by each such child

rough

2.9 Results of control of the subjects including obligatory at least an amount of knowledge of students and their skills determining basic level of development

considerable

2.10 The organization of individual free training at home in the presence of students who for health reasons cannot visit for a long time the organization of education

considerable

2.11 Creation of conditions for education, correction of violation of development and social adaptation by students with limited opportunities in development in the presence of those

considerable

2.12 Compliance of working curricula to standard curricula and state obligatory standard of education

rough

2.13 Share of teachers of the highest and first category for whom principle place of employment is the licensee from total number of teachers at least 20%

considerable

2.14 Availability of fund of educational literature in relation to the contingent of students, including on training languages, for the complete period of training according to the state obligatory standards of formation of the Republic of Kazakhstan and standard curricula of primary education

considerable

2.15 Availability of medical attendance of students

considerable

2.16 Food object availability for students

considerable

2.17 Availability own or belonging on the right of economic maintaining or operational management of the tangible assets providing quality of educational services

rough

2.18 Acceptance in 1 class of all children who are living in the territory of servicing of the state organization of education, reached by September 1 of the next academic year of six (seven) years irrespective of level of training, based on the statement from legal representatives of the child

considerable

2.19 Availability of orders of the head of the organization of education on transfer in the organization of education

insignificant

2.20 Availability of the contract for provision of educational services on paid basis signed between the organization of education and legal representatives of the student according to the Standard agreement of rendering educational services (for the private organizations of education)

insignificant

2.21 Availability of the license for educational activities

rough

2.22 Accomplishment of obligations by the head or other official of the organization of education for safety of health of pupils, students and employees of the organizations of education during educational and educational process (it is checked in the presence of the address)

considerable

2.23 Passing by pedagogical workers of certification at least once in five years

insignificant

2.24 Functioning of collegiate organs of management of the organization of education

considerable

2.25 Security with the personnel having the pedagogical education confirmed by documents of the state sample on appropriate level of education and qualification

rough

2.26 Non-admission to work in the organization of formation of persons to which pedagogical activities are prohibited by the court verdict or the medical certificate, and also having criminal record which is not extinguished or is not removed in the procedure established by the law

rough

2.27 Availability of working training programs in subjects of the curriculum

rough

2.28 Availability in the schedule of studies of break of sufficient duration for food and active recreation of students and pupils

insignificant

2.29 Compliance of duration of lessons in the organizations of education - to forty five minutes (in special classes - to no more than forty minutes)

insignificant

2.30 Compliance of day academic load, irrespective of duration of educational week, for studying at elementary school - no more than five lessons

considerable

2.31 Carrying out intermediate certification the studying initial classes

considerable

2.32 Carrying out the current assessment of level of development of training material and intermediate certification of the studying 1 classes

considerable

3. Availability and the number of the confirmed claims and addresses

3.1 Availability of 1-2 confirmed claims and addresses from physical persons and legal entities which rights are violated

considerable

3.2 Availability 3 (three) and more confirmed claims and addresses from physical persons and legal entities which rights are violated

rough

4. Results of the state certification

4.1 It is not certified for results of the state certification

considerable

4.2 Not execution of the instruction (resolution) on elimination of the violations revealed during the state certification of the organizations of education for discrepancy of educational services to requirements of the state obligatory standard of education

rough

5. Data of state bodies, mass media

5.1 Availability of data in mass media on violations in work of the organization of education

insignificant

5.2 Availability of instructions of bodies of prosecutor's office about the violations revealed in education organization activity

considerable

Appendix 3

to Criteria for evaluation of risk degree on checks behind education system

Subjective criteria of organization activity of education, realizing general education training programs of the main secondary education

Criteria

Extent of violation

1. Results of monitoring of the reporting and the data represented by the checked subject including by means of the automated information systems

1.1 Not submission of the reporting in the field of education

considerable

1.2 Discrepancy of data regarding general information on the organization of education and school enrollment in different types of the reporting

insignificant

1.3 Discrepancy of data regarding data on educational process, material resources and pedagogical personnel in different types of the reporting

considerable

1.4 Availability of the teachers who do not have vocational pedagogical or professional education on the corresponding profile or post

rough

1.5 Discrepancy of high-quality list of teachers to the qualification requirements imposed when licensing educational activities

considerable

1.6 Availability of subjects of the standard curriculum which are not taught because of the absence of specialists

rough

1.7 Lack of office of physics

considerable

1.8 Lack of office of chemistry

considerable

1.9 Lack of office of biology

considerable

1.10 Profound studying of objects (chemistry, biology, physics, languages) in the absence of specialized office

considerable

1.11 Lack of educational workshops

considerable

1.12 Lack of office of information science

considerable

1.13 Lack of Internet access of the computers used in educational process

considerable

1.14 Absence of library

considerable

1.15 Availability of the pupils who are not provided with textbooks

rough

1.16 Lack of the gym

considerable

1.17 Lack of the standard sports equipment in the gym

considerable

1.18 Availability of repeaters

considerable

1.19 Availability of the graduation classes combined with other classes

considerable

1.20 Availability of the graduates employed for work after the 9th class

considerable

1.21 Availability of the graduates of the 9th class who are not employed and did not continue training in the 10th class the organizations giving secondary education

considerable

1.22 Availability of three-shift training at school

considerable

1.23 Lack of the license for educational activities

rough

2. Results of the previous checks (severity is established in case of non-compliance with following requirements)

2.1 Availability constituent and documents of title of the organization of education

considerable

2.2 Accomplishment of obligations and regulations of pedagogical ethics by the pedagogical worker (it is checked in the presence of addresses)

considerable

2.3 Respect for the principle of state policy regarding prohibition of creation and activities of organizational structures of political parties and the religious organizations (associations) in the organizations of education

rough

2.4 Passing by the head of the organization of formation of certification once in three years

insignificant

2.5 Advanced training of the managerial personnel, pedagogical and scientists of the organizations of education at least once in five years

insignificant

2.6 Accomplishment of invariant component of the standard curriculum

rough

2.7 Compliance of the maximum amount of week academic load of students, including all types of cool and out-of-class study (optional, individual and kruzhkovy occupations), to the state obligatory standard of secondary education (the main average)

rough

2.8 Division of class into 2 groups in the city general education organizations at filling class in 24 and more students, in rural - in 20 and more students, in small schools - at least 10 students when carrying out lessons:

1) on Kazakh in 5-9 classes with not Kazakh of training;

2) on the Kazakh literature in 5-9 classes with not Kazakh of training;

3) on Russian in 5-9 classes with the Kazakh and Uigur, Tajik and Uzbek languages of training;

4) on foreign language in 5-9 classes;

5) on information science in 5-9 classes;

6) in profile objects;

7) on technology 5-9 classes (groups of boys and girls irrespective of fullness of class);

8) on physical culture in 5-9 classes.

In the presence in class of children with limited opportunities in development division of class is performed at the rate of reduction of total quantity of pupils by three by each such child

rough

2.9 Results of control of the subjects including obligatory at least an amount of knowledge of students and their skills determining basic level of development

considerable

2.10 The organization of individual free training at home in the presence of students who for health reasons cannot visit for a long time the organization of education

considerable

2.11 Creation of conditions for education, correction of violation of development and social adaptation of students with limited opportunities in development in the presence of those

considerable

2.12 Compliance of working curricula to standard curricula and state obligatory standard of education

rough

2.13 Share of teachers of the highest and first category for whom principle place of employment is the licensee from total number of teachers - at least 30%

considerable

2.14 Availability of fund of educational literature in relation to the contingent of students, including on training languages, for the complete period of training, educational and methodical complexes and digital educational resources according to the state obligatory standards of formation of the Republic of Kazakhstan and standard curricula of the main secondary education

considerable

2.15 Availability of medical attendance of students

considerable

2.16 Food object availability for students

considerable

2.17 Availability own or belonging on the right of economic maintaining or operational management of the tangible assets providing quality of educational services

rough

2.18 Equipment the computer classes connected to the Internet; educational laboratory equipment; educational subject offices according to the state obligatory standard of education

considerable

2.19 Acceptance of students in 5-9 classes of the organizations of education realizing training programs of the main secondary education, which finished the level of primary education is performed according to the decision of the commission created by the order of the head of the organization of education

considerable

2.20 Ensuring access of all studying 5-9 classes living in the territory of servicing of the state organization of education taking into account interests of legal representatives

considerable

2.21 Acceptance on competitive basis in the specialized organizations of education for exceptional children

insignificant

2.22 Availability of the contract for provision of educational services on paid basis signed between the organization of education and legal representatives of the student according to the Standard agreement of rendering educational services (for the private organizations of education)

insignificant

2.23 Availability of the license for educational activities

rough

2.24 Accomplishment of obligations by the head or other official of the organization of education for safety of health of pupils, students and employees of the organizations of education during educational and educational process (it is checked in the presence of the address)

considerable

2.25 Passing by pedagogical workers of certification at least once in five years

insignificant

2.26 Functioning of collegiate organs of management of the organization of education

considerable

2.27 Security with the personnel having the pedagogical education confirmed by documents of the state sample on appropriate level of education and qualification

rough

2.28 Non-admission to work in the organization of formation of persons to which pedagogical activities are prohibited by the court verdict or the medical certificate, and also having criminal record which is not extinguished or is not removed in the procedure established by the law

rough

2.29 Availability of working training programs in subjects of the curriculum

rough

2.30 Availability of the lesson schedule of the educational process developed on the basis of the curriculum

insignificant

2.31 Compliance of duration of lessons in the organizations of education - to forty five minutes (in special classes - to no more than forty minutes)

insignificant

2.32 Compliance of day academic load, irrespective of duration of educational week, for studying at the main school - no more than seven

considerable

2.33 Availability in the schedule of studies of break of sufficient duration for food and active recreation of students and pupils

considerable

2.34 Issue to the citizens who passed final assessment, education documents of the state sample

considerable

2.35 Transfer of pupils of 5-8 classes in the following class

considerable

2.36 Carrying out the current control of progress of students

considerable

2.37 The admission of the studying 5-8 classes to intermediate certification

considerable

2.38 Carrying out intermediate certification of the studying 5-8 classes

considerable

2.39 Carrying out repeated intermediate certification of the studying 5-8 classes

insignificant

2.40 The admission of the studying 9 classes to final assessment

considerable

2.41 Holding final assessment of the studying 9 classes

considerable

2.42 Holding repeated final assessment, the studying 9 classes which received unsatisfactory estimates in 1-2 objects

considerable

3. Availability and the number of the confirmed claims and addresses

3.1 Availability of 1-2 confirmed claims and addresses from physical persons and legal entities which rights are violated

considerable

3.2 Availability 3 (three) and more confirmed claims and addresses from physical persons and legal entities which rights are violated

rough

4. Results of external assessment of educational achievements

4.1 Availability of the students who got 0 points in objects of the external assessment of educational achievements (EAEA)

considerable

4.2 Availability of the students who gained less than 50% of the correct answers of total quantity of questions VOUD

considerable

5. Results of the state certification

5.1 It is not certified for results of the state certification

considerable

5.2 Not execution of the instruction (resolution) on elimination of the violations revealed during the state certification of the organizations of education for discrepancy of educational services to requirements of the state obligatory standard of education

rough

6. Data of state bodies, mass media

6.1 Availability of data in mass media on violations in work of the organization of education

insignificant

6.2 Availability of instructions of bodies of prosecutor's office about the violations revealed in education organization activity

considerable

Appendix 4

to Criteria for evaluation of risk degree on checks behind education system

Subjective criteria of organization activity of education, realizing general education training programs of general secondary education

Criteria

Extent of violation

1. Results of monitoring of the reporting and the data represented by the checked subject including by means of the automated information systems

1.1 Not submission of the reporting in the field of education

considerable

1.2 Discrepancy of data regarding general information on the organization of education and school enrollment in different types of the reporting

insignificant

1.3 Discrepancy of data regarding data on educational process, material resources and pedagogical personnel in different types of the reporting

considerable

1.4 Availability of the teachers who do not have vocational pedagogical or professional education on the corresponding profile or post

rough

1.5 Discrepancy of high-quality list of teachers to the qualification requirements imposed when licensing educational activities

considerable

1.6 Availability of subjects of the standard curriculum which are not taught because of the absence of specialists

rough

1.7 Lack of office of physics

considerable

1.8 Lack of office of chemistry

considerable

1.9 Lack of office of biology

considerable

1.10 Profound studying of objects (chemistry, biology, physics, languages) in the absence of specialized office

considerable

1.11 Lack of educational workshops

considerable

1.12 Lack of office of information science

considerable

1.13 Lack of Internet access of the computers used in educational process

considerable

1.14 Absence of library

considerable

1.15 Availability of the pupils who are not provided with textbooks

rough

1.16 Lack of the gym

considerable

1.17 Lack of the standard sports equipment in the gym

considerable

1.18 Availability of repeaters

considerable

1.19 Availability of the graduates of the 11th class who received the reference of the corresponding sample (with record "listened"), following the results of completion of academic year

insignificant

1.20 Availability of the graduation classes combined with other classes

considerable

1.21 Availability of three-shift training at school

considerable

1.22 Lack of the license for educational activities

rough

Warning!!!

This is not a full text of document! Document shown in Demo mode!

If you have active License, please Login, or get License for Full Access.

With Full access you can get: full text of document, original text of document in Russian, attachments (if exist) and see History and Statistics of your work.

Get License for Full Access Now

Disclaimer! This text was translated by AI translator and is not a valid juridical document. No warranty. No claim. More info

Effectively work with search system

Database include more 50000 documents. You can find needed documents using search system. For effective work you can mix any on documents parameters: country, documents type, date range, teams or tags.
More about search system

Get help

If you cannot find the required document, or you do not know where to begin, go to Help section.

In this section, we’ve tried to describe in detail the features and capabilities of the system, as well as the most effective techniques for working with the database.

You also may open the section Frequently asked questions. This section provides answers to questions set by users.

Search engine created by SojuzPravoInform LLC. UI/UX design by Intelliants.